When it comes to English police reform, do not repeat the mistakes made north of the border

Mace | 5th June 2026 | Comment, Law Enforcement and Crime, Politics
Photo by Finnbarr Webster/Getty Images
Photo by Finnbarr Webster/Getty Images

The dismal results of reducing the police force in Scotland should act as a cautionary deterrent for English police reform, writes Sharon Dowey, a former member of the Scottish Parliament’s criminal justice committee.

Westminster may not think it has much to take a lead from in relation to Holyrood, Scotland’s concrete parliament building in the heart of Edinburgh. But at the very least, it must not replicate one of its greatest mistakes.

The UK Government announced earlier this year it wanted to reduce the number of police forces in England from 43 down to between 10 and 20. It would be a humungous amalgamation, and one of the biggest public sector reforms to have taken place in Britain for decades.

As the proposals are being considered, many are wondering what the end result would look like.

They should look no further than the dire state of affairs currently afflicting policing and justice in Scotland, the only part of the UK to have gone through anything like a merger on this scale. In 2013 Police Scotland was created out of eight legacy forces, and is now one of the UK’s largest.

It means diverse organisations like Strathclyde Police, which were responsible for the mean streets of Glasgow, were thrown together with the likes of Northern Constabulary, which patrolled a gigantic geographical area made up of islands, remote communities and some of Europe’s last true wilderness regions.

We’re now more than a decade in, and the results have been catastrophic. The move was all about efficiencies, and some Scottish Government ministers even boasted about savings of around £200 million a year …

Subscribe to The Mace

Join the member community shaping British politics and stay ahead of what's really happening in the world of politics and public affairs, with expert analysis, breaking news, and insider insights from Westminster and Brussels. The Mace is the leading news source and resource for the government affairs industry, offering required reading and lobby intelligence for professionals.

To see what you are missing out on by not subscribing to The Mace, click here to download our full membership info-pack. This includes having no paywall on op-ed content or profiles/interviews, allowing professional profiles to be read with maximum impact and visibility by government, special advisers, MPs, peers, civil servants, and policy and political decision-makers.



Burnham’s popularity bubble is doomed to pop  

Lucy Carrier-Pilkington | June 23, 2026

Andy Burnham wants an immediate coronation, but life in Westminster would quickly expose the limits of popular appeal built from a safe distance. 

Keir Starmer resigns as Prime Minister as Labour prepares for Burnham succession

Emelia Wild | June 22, 2026

Sir Keir Starmer has announced that he will resign as Prime Minister and leader of the Labour Party, triggering a leadership process that now looks increasingly likely to

Hail Andy, King of Makerfield 

William Cash | June 19, 2026

As vultures circle Downing Street, now that Burnham is back as an MP, Starmer must realise that resigning is going to be better for the Labour Party than

Musical chairs again in Downing Street

Lucy Carrier-Pilkington | June 18, 2026

What will a Burnham government look like ? Lucy Carrier-Pilkington analyses what a change of prime minister will mean for the country and who will be the likely

‘Al is a born leader’: The dark horse of the Labour leadership contest 

Lucy Carrier-Pilkington | June 16, 2026

Ex-Royal Marines commando emerges as the plan B candidate in the race for Labour leadership.

The social media ban: game changer or rushed job?

Lucy Carrier-Pilkington | June 16, 2026

Debate has erupted over whether the new policy is an overdue attempt to rein in Silicon Valley or a short-sighted, politically motivated move that will push children towards

Reform v Restore: the English civil war in Makerfield that will decide the next Labour prime minister

William Cash | June 15, 2026

With Restore and Reform tearing votes off each other, the Makerfield by-election could propel Andy Burnham into Number 10. But, asks William Cash, will Restore's percentage of the

Memo to the new Defence Secretary before the NATO summit: “It’s not all about the money”

Mace | June 12, 2026

Creating a Defence Industrial base with no new money is going to be a challenge for any Defence Secretary. But, argues defence expert William Wallace, there are several

Social media crackdown: “Those who use social media to incite violence and disorder are breaking the law”  

Lucy Carrier-Pilkington | June 11, 2026

Twelve police officers have been injured and 16 people arrested in the second night of rioting in Northern Ireland, Technology Secretary responds with a new crackdown.

Reflections on May: London’s new political landscape

Jonny Popper | June 11, 2026

May’s local elections completely transformed London’s political landscape, argues CEO Jonny Popper.