When it comes to English police reform, do not repeat the mistakes made north of the border

Mace | 5th June 2026 | Comment, Law Enforcement and Crime, Politics
Photo by Finnbarr Webster/Getty Images
Photo by Finnbarr Webster/Getty Images

The dismal results of reducing the police force in Scotland should act as a cautionary deterrent for English police reform, writes Sharon Dowey, a former member of the Scottish Parliament’s criminal justice committee.

Westminster may not think it has much to take a lead from in relation to Holyrood, Scotland’s concrete parliament building in the heart of Edinburgh. But at the very least, it must not replicate one of its greatest mistakes. The UK Government announced earlier this year it wanted to reduce the number of police forces in England from 43 down to between 10 and 20. It would be a humungous amalgamation, and one of the biggest public sector reforms to have taken place in Britain for decades. As the proposals are being considered, many are wondering what the end result would look like. They should look no further than the dire state of affairs currently afflicting policing and justice in Scotland, the only part of the UK to have gone through anything like a merger on this scale. In 2013 Police Scotland was created out of eight legacy forces, and is now one of the UK’s largest. It means diverse organisations like Strathclyde Police, which were responsible for the mean streets of Glasgow, wer...

Subscribe to The Mace

Join the member community shaping British politics and stay ahead of what's really happening in the world of politics and public affairs, with expert analysis, breaking news, and insider insights from Westminster and Brussels. The Mace is the leading news source and resource for the government affairs industry, offering required reading and lobby intelligence for professionals.

To see what you are missing out on by not subscribing to The Mace, click here to download our full membership info-pack. This includes having no paywall on op-ed content or profiles/interviews, allowing professional profiles to be read with maximum impact and visibility by government, special advisers, MPs, peers, civil servants, and policy and political decision-makers.



Murder on the Dancefloor: Is the budget killing Britain’s nightclubs?

Lucy Carrier-Pilkington | November 19, 2026

Britain's nightclubs are closing at an alarming rate, but the latest budget has offered them no lifeline

CEO reacts to Milburn Review: “The report is ambitious, and rightly so”

Robert Richardson | November 19, 2026

The Milburn Report sets out an ambitious plan to tackle the UK’s youth employment crisis, Robert Richardson, CEO of the Institute of Hospitality, has considered the role hospitality

The SNP’s promise of cheaper energy is all hot air

Liam Kerr | November 17, 2026

The Prime Minister is a known advocate of devolution, and it has taken the SNP little time to exploit this for their own ends.

Rewiring Whitehall: Dame Antonia’s burning desire for change

Mace Magazine | November 10, 2026

At tonight's LSE lecture, Dame Antonia Romeo, Britain's top civil servant promises a revolution, arguing there is a "burning" need for reform.

The ex-Cameron outsider who ran out of road in California

William Cash | November 4, 2026

Steve Hilton, David Cameron's one-time guru, has lost his bid to become California's first Republican governor in 20 years. So where does a man of so many reinventions

Donald, the lame duck: Trump after the midterms

William Cash | November 4, 2026

Trump told America to treat the midterms as a vote on him. It did. Now comes the reckoning, writes Mace editor-in-chief William Cash from California.

Tough Love: Is cutting benefits for young people fair?

Lucy Carrier-Pilkington | November 3, 2026

It sounds like a straightforward fix: fewer young people on benefits, more in work. But is the reality so simple?

Steve Hilton’s California gamble

William Cash | November 2, 2026

A former Downing Street strategist is standing to be elected as the first Republican governor in 20 years. He's campaigning as if the polls are wrong.

UK Budget 2026: Energy Bill Relief, North Sea Oil and Gas, and the Cost of Britain’s Green Transition

Anna Bryzhko | October 29, 2026

The government has promised to ease energy bills while investing in Britain's energy future. But can it support North Sea production, expand clean power and meet climate commitments

Found the Budget boring? Burnham may be thinking of an early election

Lucy Carrier-Pilkington | October 28, 2026

After weeks of anticipation, Healey’s maiden budget looks to designed to re-assure the markets that Labour are fiscally responsible.