Did a “boys club” culture of Downing Street lead to the appointment of Peter Mandelson ?

Mace | 29th April 2026 | Comment, Editor's Pick, Politics
Dan Kitwood
Dan Kitwood

Keir Starmer's "boys club" culture was called out during the grilling of Morgan McSweeney.

As Lib Dem leader Ed Davey rightly said, the ‘original sin’ of the Mandelson vetting scandal was that the Labour peer was put up for the role of US ambassador in the first place.   This point was hammered home by Dame Emily Thornberry during the grilling of Morgan McSweeney in the House of Commons today, where she pressed him about the attempts to give the former director of communications, Lord Matthew Doyle, a comfortable ambassadorial role.   Dame Emily hit out: “Haven't you heard of the phrase jobs for the boys?”  She added it was “shameful” that Downing Street even considered giving someone a landing spot after they were sacked.   Matthew Doyle was suspended for his association with a charged distributor of indecent images of children.  However, Dame Emily’s argument also rings true for the controversial behaviour of Morgan McSweeney in trying to secure Mandelson the Washington job.   Although McSweeney is attempting to rebut out against the tight-knit caricature of his relationship with Mandelson - their longstanding political allyship is unquestionable.  Mandelson and McSweeney both started their political careers at Lambeth council – originally one of New Labour’s success stories, but by 2002 it took a hard fight from McSweeney to retake it from the Conservativesand Liberal Democrats.   They were reintroduced later in their political lives by Labour peer Roger Liddle – another Lambeth council veteran – in 2017, the pair remained in very regular contact up until Mandelson was sacked as ambassador.  Both men had their political differences but were united in their professional interest to win against the Labour left and destroy it.    They also were both able to exercise significant influence through their respective lobbying firm and think tank – Global Counsel and Labour Together.   With this in mind, it then becomes less surprising that McSweeney helped place the man he once described as a mentor into one of the most prestigious roles in government – despite the already known controversies of Mandelson’s career and concerns about his character.   With the help of McSweeney’s Labour Together, Keir Starmer became leader of the Labour Party in April 2020 – with McSweeney as his Chief of Staff by 2024.  Despite Mandelson's brutal criticisms of Starmer, he remained in proximity to the leader through his relationship with McSweeney – Mandelson's growing influence raised red flags in Labour HQ, with staffer Simon Fletcher saying he was alarmed to learn of Mandelsons growing influence.   Mandelson was also a regular attendee of the Sunday supper club held at Liddle’s home – frequent guests also included McSweeney and Doyle.   Sue Gray, Starmer’s then Chief of Staff, was concerned about Mandelson’s growing influence, one staffer said: “She knew he was after a job, she took him off the shortlist to be ambassador.”  Mandelson, who had been forced to resign in 1998 as trade and industry secretary, and 2001 as Northern Ireland secretary, was then appointed as US ambassador in December 2024.   Most employers, after an individual has been sacked from their organisation twice, would not think to rehire them for a third time and appoint them in one of their highest positions possible – however, this clearly is part of the culture of Starmer's Downing Street.   Despite the aghast looks of McSweeney in the House of Commons today – Emma Thornberry's accusation of a ‘jobs for the boys’ culture was not unfair – as how did such a controversial politician like Mandelson make itso far? And how on earth was disgraced Doyle considered for a diplomatic role?   This is not the first time that Starmer's government has faced such accusations, only in February did cabinet member, Lisa Nandy, suggest Labour had bee...

Subscribe to The Mace

Join the member community shaping British politics and stay ahead of what's really happening in the world of politics and public affairs, with expert analysis, breaking news, and insider insights from Westminster and Brussels. The Mace is the leading news source and resource for the government affairs industry, offering required reading and lobby intelligence for professionals.

To see what you are missing out on by not subscribing to The Mace, click here to download our full membership info-pack. This includes having no paywall on op-ed content or profiles/interviews, allowing professional profiles to be read with maximum impact and visibility by government, special advisers, MPs, peers, civil servants, and policy and political decision-makers.

Wigan Man will decide the next Prime Minister

Mace | June 1, 2026

Andy Burnham may struggle to win the Makerfield by-election if ‘Wigan Man’ emerges as the new median voter whom parties must attract to win the next election, says

Brussels Diary by Konstantinos Bogdanos: ‘The local bistros are half-empty as the Belgian middle class finds even a weekend meal an unaffordable luxury”

Konstantinos Bogdanos | May 26, 2026

Konstantinos Bogdanos, our regular Brussels Diarist, on how the bills for Europe’s political class are finally coming due in a city where the Belgian middle-class can't afford to

Time’s up on late payments: How large companies are harming UK’s smaller businesses

Mace | May 24, 2026

Graeme Donnelly, CEO and founder of 1st Formations, explains why the King’s Speech’s proposed crackdown on late payments will help the SME economy.

Holiday tax will ruin the English Summer

Mace | May 23, 2026

Despite the new 5% VAT tax break for holiday attractions, tourism trade body leaders are speaking out about how government policies may not help the sector.

The Strategist: Dominic Raab, former deputy prime minister joins Kreab London as senior adviser

Mace | May 22, 2026

The former deputy prime minister and foreign secretary will be advising Kreab global clients on defence and intelligence-related issues, as well as international geopolitics and Westminster issues.

The Downing Street revolving door undermines democracy and weakens policymaking

Lucy Carrier-Pilkington | May 21, 2026

With the battle for Labour's leadership far from over, Lucy Carrier-Pilkington analyses what a change in leader could mean for policymaking.

The Stress Test executive boards should not ignore 

Markus Leutert | May 20, 2026

The companies that will emerge with their reputation intact will be those that treat brand coherence as a governance discipline.

Leader in UK Public Affairs: Jessica Lennard, Chief Strategy Officer, Competition and Markets Authority – “I’m an obsessive starter finisher”

Mace | May 20, 2026

After leaving Linklaters, Jessica joined the Conservative Party’s Shadow Energy and Climate Change team in 2008 just as energy security and climate policy were rising rapidly up the

Time to pay-up: why the government is right to crack-down on late payments by large companies

Mace | May 20, 2026

New legislation in the King's Speech to clamp down on large companies paying small suppliers late is long overdue, says Sarah Stone

Are Labour eyeing a return to the EU? Mace investigates the key players involved 

Lucy Carrier-Pilkington | May 19, 2026

Recent comments by the former health secretary have plunged Brexit back into national conversation, but what does Labour actually think?