Do outsiders in government really work?

Mace | 4th June 2026 | Policy & Think Tanks, Politics

As politicians call for more external appointments in Whitehall, Professor Nada Kakabadse argues that the real challenge lies not in recruitment, but governance.

In the space of a single week earlier this year, Tony Blair argued that government departments should be led by ministers recruited from outside of Parliament. Reform UK unveiled plans to give ministers greater powers over senior civil service appointments. At the same time, the government continued advancing its own reform agenda, including efforts to bring more outside expertise into Whitehall.

Different parties and politics. And yet on this point they seem to be remarkably aligned: Britain needs more people from beyond Westminster and Whitehall to help run the state. They could well be right.

What is more striking, however, is how little of the current debate engages with the evidence accumulated over decades of trying exactly this.

Britain has been attempting to bring more external expertise into government since the Fulton Report in 1968. More than half a century later, the Institute for Government still concludes that Whitehall struggles to attract, retain and properly use specialist knowledge from wider society.

The difficulty is that politicians often talk about ‘bringing in outsiders’ as though it means one thing. It doesn’t. Recruiting technical specialists into the civil service, appointing an external leader to run a major government function, and bringing ministers into government from outside Parliament are entirely different propositions. Each action raises …

Subscribe to The Mace

Join the member community shaping British politics and stay ahead of what's really happening in the world of politics and public affairs, with expert analysis, breaking news, and insider insights from Westminster and Brussels. The Mace is the leading news source and resource for the government affairs industry, offering required reading and lobby intelligence for professionals.

To see what you are missing out on by not subscribing to The Mace, click here to download our full membership info-pack. This includes having no paywall on op-ed content or profiles/interviews, allowing professional profiles to be read with maximum impact and visibility by government, special advisers, MPs, peers, civil servants, and policy and political decision-makers.

Carry on, Clacton

William Cash | August 18, 2026

Wiliam Cash reflects on how the myth of Clacton and its reality has created media distortion when it comes to reporting on Farage’s seaside spiritual HQ.

The Clacton by-election: “It has been amazing for business”

Ella Beadman and Lucy Carrier-Pilkington | August 10, 2026

Ahead of the Clacton-on-Sea by-election this Thursday, Mace went to the constituency to hear what local businesses make of the media circus that has descended on the seaside town, and the changes they want

Burnham is trying to fix Whitehall, but will the political machinery change?

Mace | August 7, 2026

Andy Burnham is shaking up government with more changes than by any incoming prime minister in memory. But, asks Sir Bernard Jenkin MP, does he understand why the

Racing the sunset: a pilgrim odyssey across a dying Europe

Mace | August 4, 2026

For 10 months, ex-army officer James Jeffrey trekked 3500 km across Europe by foot. The scale of migration he witnessed may not have been as dramatic as the

Leader in Public Affairs: Grace Pritchard, Downing Street Director of News and the Prime Minister’s Political Spokesperson

Mace | August 3, 2026

After heading the Makerfield by-election comms team, Grace Pritchard was singled out by Andy Burnham as being a key part of his northern campaign team. The self-styled 'Yorkshire