Do outsiders in government really work?

Mace | 4th June 2026 | Policy & Think Tanks, Politics
Professor Nada Kakabadese
Professor Nada Kakabadese

As politicians call for more external appointments in Whitehall, Professor Nada Kakabadse argues that the real challenge lies not in recruitment, but governance.

In the space of a single week earlier this year, Tony Blair argued that government departments should be led by ministers recruited from outside of Parliament. Reform UK unveiled plans to give ministers greater powers over senior civil service appointments. At the same time, the government continued advancing its own reform agenda, including efforts to bring more outside expertise into Whitehall.

Different parties and politics. And yet on this point they seem to be remarkably aligned: Britain needs more people from beyond Westminster and Whitehall to help run the state. They could well be right.

What is more striking, however, is how little of the current debate engages with the evidence accumulated over decades of trying exactly this.

Britain has been attempting to bring more external expertise into government since the Fulton Report in 1968. More than half a century later, the Institute for Government still concludes that Whitehall struggles to attract, retain and properly use specialist knowledge from wider society.

The difficulty is that politicians often talk about ‘bringing in outsiders’ as though it means one thing. It doesn’t. Recruiting technical specialists into the civil service, appointing an external leader to run a major government function, and bringing ministers into government from outside Parliament are entirely different propositions. Each action raises …

Subscribe to The Mace

Join the member community shaping British politics and stay ahead of what's really happening in the world of politics and public affairs, with expert analysis, breaking news, and insider insights from Westminster and Brussels. The Mace is the leading news source and resource for the government affairs industry, offering required reading and lobby intelligence for professionals.

To see what you are missing out on by not subscribing to The Mace, click here to download our full membership info-pack. This includes having no paywall on op-ed content or profiles/interviews, allowing professional profiles to be read with maximum impact and visibility by government, special advisers, MPs, peers, civil servants, and policy and political decision-makers.



Reform’s international policy: Farage looking to balance ideals with new foreign policy advisor

Jonathan Singh | July 16, 2026

To date, Reform is yet to appoint a foreign affairs spokesperson. Jonathan Singh looks at Reform's new approach to international affairs with the appointment of Dr Alan Mendoza

Ann Widdecombe Devon hamlet murder mystery continues as tributes make her a political saint

William Cash | July 16, 2026

The death of Ann Widdecombe raises serious questions about the security of high-profile politicians. The shocking episode seems out of Midsomer Murders with the former Tory minister being turned into

Kemi is right to lift the white, Oxbridge fatwa and purge the Conservative party of non-Tories

William Cash | July 10, 2026

Overhauling the Tory candidates list is a shrewd political move which will allow her to put her own stamp on the party, and more importantly, shape its future,

Communication: The real engine of Burnhamism  

Lucy Carrier-Pilkington | July 9, 2026

Before he has even begun, Burnham has incisively communicated his plan for the country. As MPs are scrambling for positions in cabinet, his comms team are assembling. 

Farage’s bombshell resignation: Strategy or hubris? 

Lucy Carrier-Pilkington | July 7, 2026

Farage says ‘the people of Clacton should be the judges of my actions’, but is this his most reckless move yet?  

UK’s £4.7 billion Defence black hole: Dan Jarvis is inheriting a defence settlement Britain can no longer afford

Mace Magazine | July 1, 2026

Britain cannot afford to fall behind its NATO allies on defence spending, writes Jasset Harlech.

Flint lobbyist James Purnell set to become Burnham’s chief of staff, causing unease in some Labour ranks

Mace Magazine | June 26, 2026

Flint Global CEO James Purnell's expected appointment as Andy Burnham's chief of staff is just the latest Westminster merry-go-round job move from Public Affairs back into Downing Street.

Whitehall grinds to a halt after resignation chaos  

Lucy Carrier-Pilkington | June 24, 2026

Senior advisor warns that the change of prime minister is a “colossal waste of energy”, as the business of politics comes to a standstill.

Britain is drifting towards Italian-style instability — it is time to learn from America 

Lucy Carrier-Pilkington | June 23, 2026

Love or hate the current American administration, at least they have a consistent electoral cycle where the choice of the electorate is upheld.  

Keir Starmer resigns as Prime Minister as Labour prepares for Burnham succession

Emelia Wild | June 22, 2026

Sir Keir Starmer has announced that he will resign as Prime Minister and leader of the Labour Party, triggering a leadership process that now looks increasingly likely to