Scathing criticism

Christopher Silvester | Issue 7 | Comment, Culture & Travel, Magazine, Uncategorised

From the Archive

Elizabeth,_Philip,_Charles_and_Anne

From self-lacerating memoir to by-election madness and a Labour Together takedown, The Mace’s literary editor Christopher Silvester rounds up the latest political books.

Peter Oborne was once a conservative political commentator, who wrote mainly for the Daily Telegraph and the Spectator, but over the years he has become an increasingly radical critic of both the Conservative Party and the British state (including Labour governments). The moment that turned him, if you like, was the Iraq War and the deception practiced by Tony Blair’s government over the death of scientific adviser David Kelly. “I went mentally into opposition to the British state,” he has said. There followed several books that challenged conventional views, including The Rise of Political Lying (2005), The Triumph of the Political Class (2007), and The Assault on Truth: Boris Johnson and the Emergence of a New Moral Barbarism (2021). In his latest book, Complicit: Britain’s Role in the Destruction of Gaza, Oborne attacks the British establishment’s reaction and approach to the Gaza crisis. Based on original reporting, he shows that Conservative and Labour leaderships “converged” in support of Israel’s punitive campaign in Gaza, thus creating a bipartisan “political cartel” that stifled dissenting voices, and that Britain’s media “colluded” in this enterprise. Mass protests by peaceful demonstrators have been demonised and those taking part falsely represented as terrorists. As with previous books, his criticism is scathing, and he ultimately charges that the British political and media establishment has been complicit in massacres, indiscriminate bombing, torture, ethnic cleansing and even genocide. Following on from their previous book, Greater: Britain After the Storm (2021), which won Parliamentary Book of the Year, former Conservative Cabinet minister Penny Mordaunt and global marketing entrepreneur Chris Lewis have produced a new book together, Pomp & Circumstance: Why Britain’s Traditions Matter. As befits a politician who, as Leader of the House, served as sword-bearer at the Coronation of Charles III, Mordaunt has chosen as her subject the role of tradition in modern Britain, and this is an unashamedly conservative-with-a-small-“c” book. Rejecting caricatures of Britain as an antiquated polity and casting aside prognostications of doom, the authors argue that a “predictable rhythm” helps society navigate an uncertain future. Self-confidence derived from tradition radiates down from the monarchy and parliament to local communities, where seemingly irrelevant rituals bolster shared identity and reinforce resilience in the face of both profound societal shocks and distracting passing fads. “Jolly, exuberant and brimming with affection for Britain’s rituals and traditions, this is a book that revels in our national character and looks forward with admirable optimism,” says Dominic Sandbrook, while Peter Kellner says that it is “quietly subversive and challenges readers of all parties, and none, to reflect on how best to learn from our island’s past.”...

Subscribe to The Mace

Join the member community shaping British politics and stay ahead of what's really happening in the world of politics and public affairs, with expert analysis, breaking news, and insider insights from Westminster and Brussels. The Mace is the leading news source and resource for the government affairs industry, offering required reading and lobby intelligence for professionals.

To see what you are missing out on by not subscribing to The Mace, click here to download our full membership info-pack. This includes having no paywall on op-ed content or profiles/interviews, allowing professional profiles to be read with maximum impact and visibility by government, special advisers, MPs, peers, civil servants, and policy and political decision-makers.

Are Labour eyeing a return to the EU? Mace investigates the key players involved 

Lucy Carrier-Pilkington | May 19, 2026

Recent comments by the former health secretary have plunged Brexit back into national conversation, but what does Labour actually think?

The hidden cost of doing business in the UK, and why this needs to change

Clive Wratten | May 19, 2026

The status of the UK as a leading destination for business is under threat, warns CEO Clive Wratten.

The Renters’ Right Act will bury the UK housing market, says leading UK developer Kamal Pankhania

Mace | May 19, 2026

With the UK housing market already under economic pressure, this is not the right time to introduce new rental reforms that will damage investor confidence, says Kamal Pankhania,

Governments are rich in intelligence but not capability

Nada Kakabadse | May 13, 2026

Our governments are simply not designed for the challenges we face in the modern day, warns Professor Nada Kakabadse.

Smart thinking: political debate returns to Fleet Street

William Cash | May 13, 2026

With politicians and journalists returning to Fleet Street this week, a new breed of literary festival is making political debate centre-stage.

Wes Streeting could be Britain’s next PM — here are the lobby groups who come with him 

Lucy Carrier-Pilkington | May 12, 2026

Calls for Keir Starmer to quit are getting louder, Lucy Carrier-Pilkington examines what new leadership could mean for the lobbying industry.

Why data reform is a vital asset to businesses and national services

Chris Combemale | May 12, 2026

As marketing automation becomes more sophisticated marketers must own that responsibility, says Chris Combemale.  

Starmer faces his day of reckoning

William Cash | May 12, 2026

Starmer's future hangs in the balance as Labour prepares for a potential leadership contest.

The Death of Public Trust in Westminster

Mace | May 8, 2026

The survival of our nation depends upon rebuilding trust in government between ministers and officials, says Sir Bernard Jenkin MP

The Civil Service flexi-time scandal proves work-from-home culture has gone too far 

Lucy Carrier-Pilkington | May 7, 2026

New exposé reveals civil servants have been exploiting flexible working policies at the expense of the tax payer.