Relations with Post-War Russia; a Mirror for Europe?

Szabolcs Szalay | Issue 6 | Comment, Magazine

From the Archive

Angela_Merkel_and_Vladimir_Putin_(2017-07-07)

Foreign policy planning has never been the strong asset of the European Union

Russia’s recent military losses and withdrawals in Ukraine have prompted an intense discourse about the perspectives of a post-war, and perhaps, post-Putin Russia. Although an eventual change in the Kremlin could be expected, it is still hard to predict how it might look like. Even if the United States, the European Union and several European governments, including the British, French, German or Polish have voiced their support to Ukraine as long as it takes to defeat Russia, we have to remember that we are not in 1945 and Russia is not Hitler’s Germany. Ukrainian victory will certainly not mean that Western powers will have absolute control over what is going to happen to the country with the largest territory in the world. This fact gives some uncertainty to all projections. Any discussion about Russia’s future leadership may be premature, but it is high time we pinpointed the issues that can shape Europe’s policy towards Russia. Foreign policy planning has never been a strong asset of the European Union The difficulty of reaching a consensus among the different interests of its Member States and the complexity of the EU’s decision-making process often resulted in its failure to set the agenda in world politics. The ongoing war in Ukraine seems to affect this deficiency and the threat coming from Russia has contributed to the creation of a more uniform European foreign policy, marked by stricter sanctions, military aid and a single rhetoric in the relations towards Moscow. However, the ability to find a common voice in a defensive situation does not at all mean that this attitude can still prevail once the war is over and the European countries will have to switch to a more proactive role vis-à-vis Russia. Certainly, the attempt to maintain a single European voice in foreign policy will be a serious test for the community. Different Member States’ approaches are not always easy to reconcile. Aspiring to a leading role in European foreign policy, France has always seen Russian relations as its opportunity to be a step ahead of the others in the community, while Germany was often criticised for its economy-based approach towards Russia, especially when it came to energy reliance. Despite the fact that now is a time for moderation, it is hard to believe that these reflexes, already deeply rooted in these two countries’ views on diplomacy, may soon disappear. At the same time, Poland and the Baltic states now feel more reassured than ever in their perception of Russia as a hostile nation. Although the political and economic weight of the two groups, the pragmatics and the idealistics, is hard to compare, such a difference of opinions can surely be enough to prevent the EU from finding a common position in a system that is based on consensual decision-making.  However, the lack of consensus among Member States with contrasting views on Russian relations and the inability either to reconcile opinions or to enforce a single policy could lead the community back to its pre-war situation: an EU foreign policy with weak legitimacy and Member States that go on their own way. This would be a failure of the unity and a sign that the EU will not be able to stand up in world politics as a serious actor - enormous disappointment for the friends of a stronger EU. Nevertheless, when it comes to France, Germany and other Member States unlikely to advocate for strict isolation of Russia on an emotional basis, there is still one question left. What can Russia offer to them? Whenever Russian economic relations are discussed, the first question that comes up is energy. Still far from the ultimate solution, the EU has nonetheless started to look for alternatives. Europe is already importing energy from other sources. However, moving forward with renewable and green energy in the long run has already been a major objective of the community before the war and the current situation has justified it. In this case, ambitions to tackle climate change and increase Europe’s strategic autonomy coincide perfectly. It is clear that the longer it takes to end the war, the less demand Europe will have for Russian energy. Even though EU countries might lose their interest in Russia as a source of energy, it will certainly not be the case with Russian markets. Abandoned by many European companies and seriously hit by the sanctions, Russia’s economy is not going through its best period. It has already slid in recession in the third quarter of 2022 as GDP dropped by 4 percent and projections show the decline will be permanent in the next years, contracting by 3,4 percent in 2022 and 2,3 percent in 2023  Currently, it is impossible to predict how long the sanctions will remain in force, but it is sure they will not be abandoned soon. At the same time, we can assume that once in the future the sanctions are lifted and there is a certain level of legal stability, Russia will be a promising market for European and western companies as it is a large e...

Subscribe to The Mace

Join the member community shaping British politics and stay ahead of what's really happening in the world of politics and public affairs, with expert analysis, breaking news, and insider insights from Westminster and Brussels. The Mace is the leading news source and resource for the government affairs industry, offering required reading and lobby intelligence for professionals.

To see what you are missing out on by not subscribing to The Mace, click here to download our full membership info-pack. This includes having no paywall on op-ed content or profiles/interviews, allowing professional profiles to be read with maximum impact and visibility by government, special advisers, MPs, peers, civil servants, and policy and political decision-makers.

Ann Widdecombe Devon hamlet murder mystery continues as tributes make her a political saint

William Cash | July 16, 2026

The death of Ann Widdecombe raises serious questions about the security of high-profile politicians. The shocking episode seems out of Midsomer Murders with the former Tory minister being turned into

The Families Left Out of the Nicotine Policy Debate

Beatriz Santos | July 15, 2026

Beatriz Santos argues that both scientific evidence and lived experience should remain the foundation of policymaking, especially for understanding how people succeed in quitting cigarettes.

Olly Robbins shows Whitehall is prepared to hold Westminster to account

Lucy Carrier-Pilkington | July 14, 2026

The former head of the Foreign Office is now taking legal action, putting the government's treatment of senior civil servants under fresh scrutiny.

Kemi is right to lift the white, Oxbridge fatwa and purge the Conservative party of non-Tories

William Cash | July 10, 2026

Overhauling the Tory candidates list is a shrewd political move which will allow her to put her own stamp on the party, and more importantly, shape its future,

Burnham is right: The future lies with devolution

Gill Morris | July 1, 2026

After Andy Burnham's first major speech since the resignation, devolution has been the word on everyone's lips - Gill Morris explains why it's the way forward.

Caroline Simpson: Why devolution needs this technocrat

Lucy Carrier-Pilkington | July 1, 2026

Amid the frenzy over who Burnham will choose as his chancellor, his shrewd appointment of Caroline Simpson to lead No. 10 North has been overlooked.

UK’s £4.7 billion Defence black hole: Dan Jarvis is inheriting a defence settlement Britain can no longer afford

Mace Magazine | July 1, 2026

Britain cannot afford to fall behind its NATO allies on defence spending, writes Jasset Harlech.

CPAC GB 2026: “Save Britain, save the West” 

Mace | June 30, 2026

Introducing the inaugural Conservative Political Action Conference (CPAC) on British soil, a landmark expansion of the world's premier conservative networking brand.  

Merkel’s Legacy is in Tatters

Azeem Ibrahim OBE | June 30, 2026

How Angela Merkel Weakened the West and Handed Putin and Xi Leverage

Defence spending controversy aside, the UK cannot turn up to NATO empty-handed 

Lucy Carrier-Pilkington | June 25, 2026

Labour psychodrama is simply not as important as the UK’s diplomatic commitment to its NATO allies.