Losing precedence

François Valentin and Jorge González-Gallarza | 25th November 2021 | Magazine, Uncategorised
maksym-harbar-okn8ZIjPMxI-unsplash

The ECJ is losing out in Poland and beyond. Is the primacy of EU law ebbing away?

From abortion to the appointment of judges, the number of topics that the current Polish government and Brussels are agreeing on is dwindling. Tensions are, unsurprisingly, rising. The Polish Constitutional Tribunal’s K 3/21 decision earlier this month yanked up the emotional pressure. Why? The Polish Court essentially deemed three articles (1, 2 and 19 - all referring to the European Court of Justice) to be unconstitutional, thereby rejecting the principle of the primacy of EU law. Precedential history The primacy of EU law is he notion that EU law takes precedence over that of member states. Although it is now seen as a major organ of the nature of the Union, it was not explicitly enshrined in 1957's founding treaty. Only seven years after this did the ECJ rule that its treaties had created a new legal system in which national courts were bound to respect EU law. The Court ruled that law could not vary between member states, without making the attendant obligations contingent. Member...

Subscribe to The Mace

Join the member community shaping British politics and stay ahead of what's really happening in the world of politics and public affairs, with expert analysis, breaking news, and insider insights from Westminster and Brussels. The Mace is the leading news source and resource for the government affairs industry, offering required reading and lobby intelligence for professionals.

To see what you are missing out on by not subscribing to The Mace, click here to download our full membership info-pack. This includes having no paywall on op-ed content or profiles/interviews, allowing professional profiles to be read with maximum impact and visibility by government, special advisers, MPs, peers, civil servants, and policy and political decision-makers.



Diary: The Hack is Back

Peter Cardwell | October 3, 2020

Peter Cardwell is enjoying his retirement from SpAd life

Bring Back Politics-by-the-sea

Mace | October 3, 2020

Seaside-town voters in red wall seats helped secure the prime minister’s landslide

More money, more problems

Tim Congdon | October 2, 2020

High inflation looms in the US as the country increases the quantity of money to combat recession, writes Tim Congdon.

Erskine: Bernard Jenkin MP

Mace | October 1, 2020

Attempts to modernise the civil service, one of the great institutions of state, will put unnecessary strain on the UK constitution

Protecting our Heritage

Mace | October 1, 2020

There is perhaps no organisation that exemplifies Britain’s regional spirit of place better than English Heritage.

The Diary of a Data Miner

Adam Solomons | March 8, 2020

Mindfuck, by Christopher Wylie, reviewed by Adam Solomons

Thirty Women: Thirty Powerful Voices

Benjamin Goodwin | March 8, 2020

She Speaks: The Power of Women's Voices, by Yvette Cooper, reviewed by Benjamin Goodwin

The Rise and Fall of an Haute Couturier

Adam Solomons | March 8, 2020

Norman Hartnell: The Biography, by Michael Pick, reviewed by Adam Solomons

Unfinished Business: Brexit, Boris and the City

Benjamin Goodwin | February 8, 2020

F**K Business: The Business of Brexit, by Iain Anderson, reviewed by Benjamin Goodwin

The Scourge of the Political Celebrity

Mace | February 6, 2020

Political celebs don't win elections, they just get in the way