Erskine

Bernard Jenkin | Issue 5 | Magazine, Uncategorised

From the Archive

TheChamber

The Scottish draft Bill on gender recognition throws up uncertainties and would weaken women’s sex-based rights in the UK. Political dialogue is urgently needed

When the Labour government retained equal opportunities as a reserved power in the Scotland Act 1998, I was opposition constitutional affairs spokesman. I supported this on the grounds that the “imposition of draconian anti-discrimination laws has to be handled with great care, because it is all too easy to substitute one type of intolerance of minorities for another”. Holyrood, the Scottish parliament, now threatens to undermine this principle. The draft Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill would weaken women’s sex-based rights across the UK. 

Devolved powers are legislative powers that the UK Parliament controlled in the past, but are now devolved to the legislatures in Scotland, Northern Ireland and Wales. These include matters such as education and health. Reserved powers, as specified in the Scotland Act, for example, remain exclusively with the UK Parliament in Westminster.  

Human rights are a devolved competence. The powers to pass a gender recognition act are therefore notionally devolved, but apply only if such an act does not impact on the reserved powers. UK citizens currently have their legal sex status recorded on their birth certificate. The only way to change their recorded sex is to obtain a Gender Recognition Certificate (GRC). The sex recorded on the GRC, with a few exceptions,
is a person’s sex for ‘all purposes under the law’. Eligibility to apply for …

Subscribe to The Mace

Join the member community shaping British politics and stay ahead of what's really happening in the world of politics and public affairs, with expert analysis, breaking news, and insider insights from Westminster and Brussels. The Mace is the leading news source and resource for the government affairs industry, offering required reading and lobby intelligence for professionals.

To see what you are missing out on by not subscribing to The Mace, click here to download our full membership info-pack. This includes having no paywall on op-ed content or profiles/interviews, allowing professional profiles to be read with maximum impact and visibility by government, special advisers, MPs, peers, civil servants, and policy and political decision-makers.



“Give negotiations a chance”

Thomas Edwards | April 11, 2025

European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen addressed the EU’s planned 25% tariffs on €21 billion of U.S. goods with a mix of defiance and diplomacy. She clarified

Jordan Bardella: the hope of the French right

Mace | April 11, 2025

Marine Le Pen’s shock conviction for embezzling EU funds, with a five-year ban from public office, shook France’s political landscape. While Le Pen vows to appeal, her legal

Australia to China: No Hand-Holding in Trump’s Trade War

Mace | April 10, 2025

Australia has rejected China’s call to unite against Trump’s escalating tariffs, with Defence Minister Richard Marles stating, “We’re not about to make common cause with China.” Beijing sought

Global Fallout from U.S. Tariffs Sends Ripple Effects Across Economies

Mace | April 9, 2025

The U.S. had launched a tariff blitz with 104% levies on Chinese goods, rattling global markets as China hit back with steep retaliatory measures. Allies from the EU

Peer’s Nuclear Energy Advocacy Sparks Debate

Mace | April 9, 2025

Conservative peer Olivia Bloomfield faces scrutiny over her ties to Terrestrial Energy, raising questions about lobbying, conflicts of interest, and the revolving door between politics and industry. Her

“Everythingism”: the policy disease paralysing Britain

Gabriel Whitwam | April 8, 2025

Britain’s policymakers are trying to make every policy achieve every goal — and ending up achieving none. From spiders halting housing to carbon targets blocking diplomacy, “everythingism” is

Trump: “The Operation Is Over” — But Recession Fears Deepen

Mace | April 8, 2025

President Trump likens the U.S. economy to a patient recovering from surgery as tariffs bite. Critics warn the treatment may kill the patient before healing begins.

Major U.S. Law Firms Enter Agreements with Trump Administration Amid Executive Order Threats

Thomas Edwards | April 6, 2025

Top U.S. law firms are striking multimillion-dollar deals with the Trump administration, curbing DEI policies and offering pro bono work to avoid punitive executive orders. The moves have

Markets Tank as Trump Tariffs Ignite Global Trade Showdown

Mace | April 6, 2025

Global stock markets plunged after President Trump imposed sweeping tariffs under emergency powers, including a baseline 10% levy and up to 54% on Chinese imports. China retaliated with

Huawei Faces Brussels Courtroom Over Corruption Allegations

Mace | April 4, 2025

Huawei representatives faced a Brussels court this week, accused of corruption and money laundering linked to their lobbying efforts in the EU. As the investigation unfolds, it could