With Greens polling second, will May 7th be execution day?

William Cash | 14th March 2026 | Comment, Editor's Pick, Politics
Zack Polanski at the 2025 Green Party conference (Photo by Finnbarr Webster/Getty )
Zack Polanski at the 2025 Green Party conference (Photo by Finnbarr Webster/Getty )

The Greens surge into second place in the polls confirms that the two-party system is no longer fit for purpose. But can Starmer and Badenoch survive execution on May 7th? 

With the Green Party now beating Labour into second place in a new poll by YouGov, nobody talks about a two-party system any more. Following Hannah Spencer’s sensational win at Gorton and Denton, the Greens are up four points to 21%, snapping at the heels of Reform.  Anthony Wells, head of polling from YouGov, has said that this is because the Greens – at least to younger people, and seemingly some traditionally Labour Muslim communities – now offers a viable political option and is less of a wasted or protest vote. The YouGov poll puts Reform UK on 23%, Greens on 21%, Labour and the Tories tied on 16, both down two, and the Lib Dems remaining on 14%. The poll makes the Greens the most popular party with all voters under 50. Even more remarkably, a staggering 49% of 18-24 year olds would back the Greens which must be putting considerable fear in Labour MPs, not the party supported lowering the voting age to sixteen. Writing in the Guardian, Green leader Zack Polanski has said that his party’s by-election win - in a seat that was 127th on his target list - has ‘changed everything’ in British politics with Green party energy ‘only gathering force now.’ Looking ahead to May 7th, with elections for local councils, mayors and the Welsh Senedd, he ‘predicted ‘a Green wave sweeping England and Wales’.  We are in uncharted political territory. Nobody doubts that May 7th will be a day of political reckoning for both Labour and Tories with grass-root demand for heads to roll. Indeed, the old two-party paradigm hasn’t applied for some time. But that was chiefly because of the rise of Reform since last May’s local election. Less than 70 days before the 2026 local elections, it’s now the Greens that are the political show stoppers. Gone are the days of the political classes sniggering about Zolanski's former career as a breast enhancing hypnotist.  With Greens and Reform expecting to wipe out Tory and Labour votes, can both main party leaders even survive the 2026 local elections? Does execution day loom in May? I think they will both survive, or at least have a prolonged stay of execution. After the 2025 party conference season, Starmer and Badenoch both bought political time after seeing off shadowy challenges from rivals – Andy Burnham and Robert Jenrick – with stirring speeches and some well received policy ideas (abolition of stamp duty went viral for the Tories). Jenrick’s presence had hovered over the Tory conference, biding his time with fringe talk of making a mean Sunday roast and taking up boxing.  But now he’s defected to Reform, the chances of any coup against Badenoch are slim, however bad the results.  The reason is not so much because she’s upped her game at PMQs, and united the party with some tough talk. The truth is that, exactly like Starmer, the main reason she’s likely to survive the May 7th slaughter is because few serious challenger MPs actually want to be leader after a Labour/Tory massacre that will make the Battle of the Boyne look like a Wind in the Willows riverside picnic.    ‘The reality is that nobody wants to seize the crown as they don’t want to become the captain of the party when it is a s*** show. If there’s going to be a challenge it will come much later ’ one former Tory Cabinet minister’s special adviser tells The Mace. The worrying truth is that for the Tory party – which thinks of itself as the party of business – many senior corporate lobbyists were noticeably absent last year in Manchester, while others whispered that they might not even bother in 2026. Having lunch last October at the Tory conference at the near-empty restaurant of the Midland Hotel with a former Tory councillor, my companion said: “You used to have to queue for a table here. It feels like a plague has wiped out half the Tory delegates.”  On Sunday, the exhibition area – parts of which resembled a Margaret Thatcher convention, with even her clothes on display – felt ghostly. One ex-national newspaper editor, swilling a glass of wine in the Politico pub, compared the mood to the 1975 Blackpool conference after an unproven Thatcher was elected Tory leader. Yet Thatcher went on to win in 1979, so one shouldn’t write off the Tories’ capacity for ruthless reinvention.  Even if Badenoch does survive assassination after May 7th, both of the two traditional parties will lose hundreds of seats in May, with both Reform and the Greens making more fatal inroads in the UK, as well as Wales and Scotland.  A change of leader may not even make much difference to the Tories’ ratings, which have been steadily improving. The latest YouGov poll puts them just a few percentage points behind Reform. The real problem the Tories face is not leadership related but a toxic 14-year legacy and a Tory selection policy that favoured “diverse”, soft-centred and non-traditional (i.e., not white Oxbridge public school types) candidates, meaning many “wet” To...

Subscribe to The Mace

Join the member community shaping British politics and stay ahead of what's really happening in the world of politics and public affairs, with expert analysis, breaking news, and insider insights from Westminster and Brussels. The Mace is the leading news source and resource for the government affairs industry, offering required reading and lobby intelligence for professionals.

To see what you are missing out on by not subscribing to The Mace, click here to download our full membership info-pack. This includes having no paywall on op-ed content or profiles/interviews, allowing professional profiles to be read with maximum impact and visibility by government, special advisers, MPs, peers, civil servants, and policy and political decision-makers.

The uncancellable Quentin Letts

Lucy Carrier-Pilkington | August 6, 2026

As a parliamentary Boz of modern times, Quentin Letts has recently found himself under fire in the Commons press gallery. He tells us why sketch writers don't need

Racing the sunset: a pilgrim odyssey across a dying Europe

Mace | August 4, 2026

For 10 months, ex-army officer James Jeffrey trekked 3500 km across Europe by foot. The scale of migration he witnessed may not have been as dramatic as the

Leader in Public Affairs: Grace Pritchard, Downing Street Director of News and the Prime Minister’s Political Spokesperson

Mace | August 3, 2026

After heading the Makerfield by-election comms team, Grace Pritchard was singled out by Andy Burnham as being a key part of his northern campaign team. The self-styled 'Yorkshire

Dame Antonia’s key civil service reforms are ready to be supported by Whitehall, says Jonathan Freeman

Mace | August 1, 2026

The Civil Service is ready to support Dame Antonia Romeo's flagship changes to government machinery - notably relating to AI and devolution - under new prime minister Andy

Burnham is trying to fix Whitehall, but will the political machinery change?

Mace | July 30, 2026

Andy Burnham is shaking up government with more changes than by any incoming prime minister in memory. But, asks Sir Bernard Jenkin MP, does he understand why the

Experts warn more government support needed to help UK aviation meet net zero by 2050

Mace | July 30, 2026

UK aviation can decarbonise while meeting growth ambitions, but urgent government action is needed to prevent costs increasing for passengers and the sector losing its competitive edge.

Don’t rule out an early election as Burnham may see an opportunity to kick Reform, says Fred de Fossard

Fred de Fossard | July 28, 2026

With the new Prime minister championing policies which go beyond Labour’s very confined 2024 manifesto, an early election is not illogical.

Despite promises of radical change, Labour’s culture of ruling political families remains entrenched

Lucy Carrier-Pilkington | July 28, 2026

Andy Burnham's inner circle appears to perpetuate Labour's long-running culture of nepotism, and is doomed to cause frustration among backbenchers.

Kemi’s true blue purge, with help from Sir Philip May

William Cash | July 26, 2026

The news that former Home Secretary Sir Grant Shapps has failed to make the new Tory candidate list has put fear into dozens of former Conservative MPs. Whether

Why Burnham’s energy VAT cut will make a difference

Mace Magazine | July 25, 2026

Cameron Brown, a former special advisor to the Chancellor of the Exchequer, explains why Burnham's VAT cut on energy bills is a measure people will actually notice.