Governments are rich in intelligence but not capability

Nada Kakabadse | 13th May 2026 | Comment
Photo by Hannah McKay - WPA Pool/Getty Images
Photo by Hannah McKay - WPA Pool/Getty Images

Our governments are simply not designed for the challenges we face in the modern day, warns Professor Nada Kakabadse.

In 2016, the UK ran one of the most comprehensive pandemic simulations in its history. Nearly 1,000 officials took part. The conclusions were stark, but accurate. 

The system would struggle to cope, hospitals would be overwhelmed, PPE stockpiles were insufficient, and coordination across government was likely to ultimately falter. 

Four years later, COVID-19 proved every one of these warnings to be correct. The real story here isn’t that government got it wrong. It’s that it got it right, and yet still chose not to act. 

Knowing isn’t the same as being ready 

This project, known as ‘Exercise Cygnus,’ did exactly what it was designed to do. It stress-tested the system and exposed vulnerabilities with clarity and honesty. Those involved were all capable, serious professionals, but the end analysis was not the problem. It was what followed that was at issue. 

Recommendations were made, documented, and then left mostly untouched. When the crisis eventually hit, it didn’t surprise the system, it simply exploited the weaknesses which had already been mapped. 

This gap between insight and action is not unique to the UK. It is, increasingly, a defining failure of modern governance. 

Governments today are rich in diagnosis but poor in delivery. Their reports accumulate, key lessons are identified, and then implementation stall, until the next crisis arrives to validate what’s already …

Subscribe to The Mace

Join the member community shaping British politics and stay ahead of what's really happening in the world of politics and public affairs, with expert analysis, breaking news, and insider insights from Westminster and Brussels. The Mace is the leading news source and resource for the government affairs industry, offering required reading and lobby intelligence for professionals.

To see what you are missing out on by not subscribing to The Mace, click here to download our full membership info-pack. This includes having no paywall on op-ed content or profiles/interviews, allowing professional profiles to be read with maximum impact and visibility by government, special advisers, MPs, peers, civil servants, and policy and political decision-makers.



Cabinet Secretary’s exit brings turmoil to Downing Street

Oliver Dean | February 13, 2026

With Wormald being the third senior figure to exit government in recent days, questions are being raised over the long-term stability and survivability of this government

Britain must take full advantage of trade outside the EU

Ted Newson | February 12, 2026

Five years since leaving the European Union, Britain has not yet taken advantage of the levers of free trade, writes Ted Newson

PM’s right hand man criticises government communications operation

Thomas Edwards | February 9, 2026

The government’s communications operation has been publicly criticised by a senior ministerial aide who also plays a central role in overseeing that work, in a rare confrontation over

Lessons from Maggie

Michael Maslinski | February 8, 2026

The care system needs a revamp. If it continues on its current trajectory, we will all pay the price, argues Michael Maslinski

Businesses should prepare for a post-Starmer future

Oliver Dean | February 5, 2026

Starmer's position is unquestionably weak, and businesses would do well to prepare for his eventual ousting, argues Oliver Dean

Trump ruffles feathers at Davos, posing an uncertain future for NATO

Madeline Dabbah | January 29, 2026

Trump’s shifting Greenland strategy at Davos unsettles NATO, strains transatlantic trust, and leaves the UK balancing sovereignty principles against alliance stability

Why are MP’s crossing the Reform Rubicon

William Cash | January 19, 2026

As senior Conservatives continue to cross into Reform’s turquoise waters, questions grow over whether this is renewal or simply ambition dressed as principle.

Editor-In-Chief watches Jenrick Defect as Reform Courts the Conservatives

William Cash | January 16, 2026

William Cash attends a dramatic Westminster press conference at which Robert Jenrick is inducted into Reform. But how many more Tory defections are good for the party?

Gaza and the art of the deal

Mace | January 16, 2026

Trump secures ceasefire through dealmakers, but long term peace remains uncertain

The end of an era: The decline and fall of the Tory Party

Mark Fields | December 3, 2025

Former MP Mark Field – author of tell-all memoir The End of an Era – reflects on where it all went wrong for his party