Ahead of Commonwealth leaders gathering in Antigua, The Mace reports on how Brussels wants to stop the Caribbean “golden passport” trade
On 1 November, Commonwealth leaders gather in St John’s, Antigua, under the banner “Accelerating Partnerships and Investment for a Prosperous Commonwealth”. A short flight west, St Kitts and Nevis, one of the King’s smallest realms, is heading for a fiscal cliff-edge, and the strain is starting to show along the old fault line between its two islands.
For four decades, the federation has sold passports to wealthy foreigners through Citizenship by Investment (CBI). Lately it has lived on them. By the IMF’s count, CBI fees were worth 25.8% of GDP in 2022. By 2025 they were worth 6%. The deficit that year reached 11.7% of GDP, and the Fund expects public debt to climb from 58% to 78% of GDP by 2031. The Eastern Caribbean Central Bank warns that the public finances remain “highly exposed to changes in CBI activity”.
Brussels wants the Caribbean’s golden passports gone by 2028 and the lost revenue will be falling due just as old grievances return. This is not going to make diplomatic relations easy with the EU, or the UK for that matter.
In June, Brussels wrote to the five Eastern Caribbean CBI states asking them to close their programmes by 1 June 2028, or risk losing visa-free access to Schengen. In January, Washington paused immigrant visas for St Kitts and Nevis nationals as part of a wider freeze. And in March, the Home Office imposed visas on Saint Lucia, citing “the threat to border security posed by the country’s Citizenship by Investment programme”. Dominica lost UK visa-free access in 2023.
Nevis’ Premier, Mark Brantley, calls the EU’s move “an existential threat”. “Immigration policy is being weaponised against us,” he said in July. Prime Minister Terrance Drew has chosen a softer register, promising “positive engagement” with Brussels. Both know that whatever replaces CBI must be found within two years.
That is where the federation’s own politics come in. Nevis has its own Assembly, its own Premier and a right to leave the federation, written into the constitution Britain made by Order in Council in 1983. In 1998, Nevisians voted 62% for independence, short of the two-thirds required. Imagine Scotland voting 62% to leave in 2014, and staying only because the bar was set higher. A Forum of Federations brief this summer concluded that secession had “largely disappeared from the political agenda”. It was describing a federation with money.
Money is the first wedge. By the Nevis Island Administration’s figures, Nevis, home to around a quarter of the population, received 8% of CBI inflows between 2010 and 2022. It secured a 25% share only last December, as receipts fell. “The question is 25% of what?” Brantley asked. His word for the wider pattern is “islandism”: national policies that are, in his words, “St. Kitts policies masquerading as national policies”.
Energy is the second. Nevis runs on imported diesel, and its fuel surcharge has gone from nothing in May to 96 cents a unit as the Strait of Hormuz crisis drove up oil prices. Brantley blames Basseterre for letting the island’s geothermal reserves sit untouched for 20 years. His critics reply that his own administration owns the power company and owes it tens of millions. Neither argument will make this winter any more affordable for residents.
The third tension is FDI – which, when it does come in (never guaranteed), often falls victim to extended delays. Some Nevisians feel these delays disproportionately affect Nevis, rather than St Kitts. Plans for an airport on Nevis have been awaiting a federal signature for months. It is a similar story with a proposed US$1.2 billion luxury development: Nevis sees it as a lifeline, but it has sat with federal ministers on St Kitts for ten months. Basseterre, which controls immigration and citizenship, insists “The Constitution is supreme”. That is a fair principle. But an island told its main source of income is closing, and then told to wait on its main alternative, will draw its own conclusions.
None of this makes break-up imminent. But the conditions that kept secession off the agenda – steady growth and enough money to go round – are disappearing at the same time. A general election is due by August 2027; the EU’s deadline falls ten months later.
St Kitts and Nevis is a realm of the King and a Commonwealth member whose constitution was made in London. If CHOGM’s talk of partnership and investment is to mean anything, it should start with what replaces CBI for the Commonwealth’s smallest members, before Brussels answers that question for them. Otherwise the Commonwealth’s next constitutional crisis may arrive quietly, in a federation that has simply run out of reasons to stay together.