Crony Island?

Adam Solomons | Issue 2 | Magazine

From the Archive

crowny_island

Political scientists have long alleged that the UK political system is one of the world’s least corrupt. When it comes to cronyism, however, why is Westminster’s record far murkier?

When, in August 2020, the prime minister elevated a Russian oligarch, a former cricketer, and his own younger brother, to the House of Lords, surprisingly few eyebrows were raised. “Such has become the norm for appointments to the upper house”, 
Westminster shrugged. “The others do it.” It is a reality check on the state of the UK’s well-publicised democratic credentials that both observations are correct. Far from being a uniquely Johnsonian notion, packing the Lords with government-friendly peers is no new invention: long before Cash for Honours embroiled Westminster in scandal and saw then-PM Tony Blair interviewed three times by police, David Lloyd George gave out 25,000 OBEs within four years and published prices for honours including knighthoods and peerages. As well as Westminster’s second chamber of 
the legislature, the House of Lords has, over the past century and longer, become a handy vehicle for crony political appointments and donor paybacks. The charade of the prime minister’s resignation honours has implicated almost every prime minister of the modern era. It comes as little surprise that Wikipedia’s entries under “List of political scandals in the UK” dates back to 1890; it could comfortably go further. Cronyism is at the heart of almost all of them. In the beginning ... “Cronyism” was, ironically, first popularised among undergraduates at Cambridge in the 1660s. Samuel Pepys wrote of his “great chrony” in a 1665 diary entry. (This also explains the origin of “old crone”, typically an elderly woman whose age is her defining feature.) But after the sleazy appointments of the Truman administration were termed “crony” in a 1952 New York Times op-ed, the word took on its current, darker meaning. And when Harold Wilson’s infamous Lavender List sparked calls of “cronyism” on Fleet Street in 1976, the word had completed its return voyage across the Atlantic. Since then, “cronyism” has integrated into the vocabulary of UK politics and media remarkably efficiently. Despite 2017 legislation banning MPs from hiring family members to their parliamentary offices at the taxpayer’s expense, dozens still do. Within the past 18 months, Boris Johnson and Rishi Sunak have both appointed long-term friends and colleagues among their senior advisers. That’s not to mention political dynasties, which still stand strong in the House of Commons. Thirteen sitting MPs had at least one parent take a seat in the lower house. Eight have or had their spouse sit alongside them in the Commons. A further five members had a grandparent serve in the Commons, six had a sibling or an uncle elected to parliament, three had a great-grandparent serve in the 
Commons, and one member is the great-great-nephew of a former MP. That doesn’t include the House of Lords, which – by design as well as by chance – holds scores of members of the best-connected families in UK politics and high society. Good clean bias? In order to understand why cronyism has thrived in Westminster, we must first answer why old-fashioned political corruption – the sort that still poisons political societies the world over – has proved much rarer. In January, Transparency International’s Corruption Perceptions Index named the UK the twelfth cleanest country in the world, below only a handful of Scandinavian nations, Germany, Singapore and New Zealand. In fact, the UK has proved notably infertile ground for criminal activity by politicians for as long as it has had its name. Without jinxing the point, the prospect of an embezzlement scandal of the nature that recently imprisoned former French prime minister François Fillon is virtually inconceivable in Westminster. The same surely applies to South Korea’s 2018 Samsung scandal, which forced the resignation of president Park Geun-hye and the imprisonment of tech magnate Jay Y Lee for bribery. Even the frequently questionable uses of Donald Trump’s downtown Washington hotel, where T-Mobile executives spent $195,000 in the run-up to a merger application from the federal government, would be beyond the pale for the UK’s corruption watchdog. Perhaps the obvious explanation for why cronyism has instead thrived in Westminster is that, for centuries fuelled by public school ideas of duty and decorum, Britain’s frontline politicians have thought it better to preserve a comfortable status quo than to exploit it, as has proved irresistible in the forceful polities of Italy, Greece and much of Eastern Europe. Such reluctance to rinse a political system that already offers pomp and patronage to its well-heeled citizens would also explain why cronyism has become endemic in the UK’s politics and economy – so much so that the country ranked above Thailand, China and South Korea in The Economist’s inaugural crony-capitalism index five years ago. With a system of high-society honours and appointments still driven by the personal impulses of Downing Street and its allies, cronyism is far likelier than corruption to become flavour of ...

Subscribe to The Mace

Join the member community shaping British politics and stay ahead of what's really happening in the world of politics and public affairs, with expert analysis, breaking news, and insider insights from Westminster and Brussels. The Mace is the leading news source and resource for the government affairs industry, offering required reading and lobby intelligence for professionals.

To see what you are missing out on by not subscribing to The Mace, click here to download our full membership info-pack. This includes having no paywall on op-ed content or profiles/interviews, allowing professional profiles to be read with maximum impact and visibility by government, special advisers, MPs, peers, civil servants, and policy and political decision-makers.

Unspun: Private Equity and Public Affairs

Ed Amory | April 15, 2026

Private equity investing in public affairs firms only makes sense if both sides know what they want

The Mace Questionnaire: Bob Blackman MP: “It is time to rebuild our party”

Mace | March 31, 2026

The ‘pragmatic’ new chair of the 1922 Committee could shape the direction of the Conservative Party

The Pope vs Trump: Is the Vatican becoming a new super-power ?

William Cash | March 31, 2026

With a new American pope, William Cash investigates the global power dynamics behind the throne of St Peter.

Sarah Vine: Scenes from a Brexit Marriage

Mace | March 30, 2026

In her bestselling book, Sarah Vine reinvented the political wife memoir. Soon out in paperback, Melanie McDonagh sat down with the ex-wife of Michael Gove to discuss the

Special Relationships: Westminster power couples of 2026

Mace | March 25, 2026

Which special relationships are really running the country? Emily Hill surveys the top political romances in Westminster.

The Mace Questionnaire: Andrew Griffith MP, Shadow Secretary for Business and Trade

Mace | March 25, 2026

After running Sky, Andrew Griffiths become a high flying MP who rose through the Johnson and Sunak governments. In his Mace profile, the Shadow Secretary for Business and

Toby Young’s House of Lords Diary

Mace | March 24, 2026

With invitations coming in to speak at the 2026 autumn party conference season, freedom of speech campaigner Toby Young reflects on his political status 'upgrade' from hack to

Digital Confidential: Politics and technology column by Damian Collins

Mace | March 12, 2026

As AI turbocharges social media, tech giants must be held accountable says the former chair of the DCMS select committee who now leads law firm Geradin Partners' public

The Westminster art of selection: How to become an MP

Gus Carter | February 20, 2026

With Reform receiving 600 new candidate applications in 48 hours, it's clear some people still want to become an MP. Our Westminster insider reveals how to get selected

The Mace Questionnaire: Preet Gill MP

Mace | February 16, 2026

Westminster Index 2026: Edgbaston Labour MP Preet Gill reveals she's no fan of the Assisted Dying Bill but loves Jack Kerouac's On the Road. Her musical tastes range